The CBSSPortsline Top 50 Players

[oregonweim]

I know Alexander fans won't be happy lol (http://www.sportsline.com/nfl/story/10225498)

[ebsoria]

And yet ONE Bronco? A few of their o-line belong on that list!

[Zo]

BIG JA WILLIAMS!!!:cheers:

[andy]

Cant argue with 2 Bengals in the Top 10!!!

I saw Shaun A. play last year and I totally agree with him being not included.

[Jerry!Jerry!]

a lot of stretches on the list IMO...asomougha (sp?), kevin williams that high when I think Pat Williams has more of an impact anyway, kerry rhodes, ty warren

[lumm0x]

He's really stretching to include alot of positions on the list. Don't agree with alot of the ranks and many of the names.

[seahawks4ever]

Julian Peterson will make that list next year. Dude is a freak of nature. I love seeing Mr. Walter Jones up there!!!

As for Shaun...... :shifty: ......... :cheers:

[wdkantro2]

a lot of stretches on the list IMO...asomougha (sp?), kevin williams that high when I think Pat Williams has more of an impact anyway, kerry rhodes, ty warren

Prisco is one of the few writers who understands Warren's value. When he missed a game, it showed (when the pats lost to the jets). There are definitely stretches though. I find it funny that he remarks how Tory Holt is so good but never gets recognition, and still puts him below Chad Johnson. Chad is a great player, but Holt has been doing it for a damn long time.

ebsoria- I think the Broncos o-line system should be in the top 50, not the actual players ;)

[b70x7n]

Stopped reading after he said Favre wasn't even on the list.

[oregonweim]

Stopped reading after he said Joey wasn't even on the list.

fixed

[b70x7n]

fixed

Touche, good sir:salut:

[detox]

Meh, I dont agree with some players on that list.

Favre not being on it is ludacris.

I would replace acouple names with Brian Dawkins, and Troy Polamalu.

[wdkantro2]

Meh, I dont agree with some players on that list.

Favre not being on it is ludacris.

I would replace acouple names with Brian Dawkins, and Troy Polamalu.

Forgot about Dawkins. Him not making the list is a travesty. Top 3 safety in the league.

[bamasa37sb34]

Yeah, Shaun's five 1000+ yard rushing seasons, all with 15 or more total TDs, were a freakin' fluke:roll:

[sffanmike25]

Yeah, Shaun's five 1000+ yard rushing seasons, all with 15 or more total TDs, were a freakin' fluke:roll:

A complete fluke. :salut:

:D

[wdkantro2]

Yeah, Shaun's five 1000+ yard rushing seasons, all with 15 or more total TDs, were a freakin' fluke:roll:

I don't think anyone thinks he's bad, but just not as good as the press clippings say he is.

[#11 Roy Williams]

That list sucks :doh:

Alot of those players are stretches..

Andre Johnson over these WRs?

Chad Johnson
Steve Smith
Roy Williams
Marques Colston
etc. etc. etc.

JOKE!

[wdkantro2]

That list sucks :doh:

Alot of those players are stretches..

Andre Johnson over these WRs?

Chad Johnson
Steve Smith
Roy Williams
Marques Colston
etc. etc. etc.

JOKE!
Chad was above Andre ;)
I'd take Smith of AJ, but AJ had 100 catches on the Texans last year. He was beat up in 05, and in 04 he had 79 and around 1150 yards. He is very underrated and I think should be on the list.

[#11 Roy Williams]

Maybe he should be on the list, but alot lower. Wonder why Roy Williams isn't on there :ban: better year than Andre..

Roy had a better year. Roy had 82 Receptions, 1310 Yards, and 7 TDs with just as bad of a supporting cast as Johnson.

Johnson had 102ish Receptions, 1100 or so yards, and 5 TDs.

[wdkantro2]

Maybe he should be on the list, but alot lower. Wonder why Roy Williams isn't on there :ban: better year than Andre..

Roy had a better year. Roy had 82 Receptions, 1310 Yards, and 7 TDs with just as bad of a supporting cast as Johnson.

Johnson had 102ish Receptions, 1100 or so yards, and 5 TDs.

True, but keep in mind Kitna is a good QB to put numbers up, and without a running game, the Lions flung the ball all over the place, hence having two WR's with over 80 catches.

[Seahawcla]

Julian Peterson will make that list next year. Dude is a freak of nature. I love seeing Mr. Walter Jones up there!!!

As for Shaun...... :shifty: ......... :cheers:

Couldnt agree more, Walt could be a a bit low at #6 though....