Is there a better college RB right now than....

[bamasa37sb34]

Darren McFadden? If so, who do you think it is?

[Brad]

James Davis or Mike Hart.


Not sure, but they are up there. Hart is a true leader and has shown that eith his actions and seems the only that has played well in all 3 games. Also Davis has a couple runs every game where no can take him down like the 29 yard TD run vs FSU

[DNoz29]

McFadden is in a class all by himself.

[rexvos]

McFadden is in a class all by himself.

yep. too bad his coach is an idiot and they have no resemblance of a passing game.

[Tazz]

I'll take P.J. Hill over McFadden. He doesn't have as many yards as McFadden, but the YPC are about the same, Hill has twice as many rushing TDs, and he's in an offense that knows how to move the ball through the air.

[rexvos]

I'll take P.J. Hill over McFadden. He doesn't have as many yards as McFadden, but the YPC are about the same, Hill has twice as many rushing TDs, and he's in an offense that knows how to move the ball through the air.

that is why his stats are better -- if I get to chose a player, I take McFadden all day long.

[bamasa37sb34]

that is why his stats are better -- if I get to chose a player, I take McFadden all day long.

Yep, just imagine McFadden in a non-one dimensional offense.

Hart = slow. Leader? Maybe. But so is McFadden. He nearly single-handedly brought Arkansas back from a 21 point deficit.

If you would rather have Davis than McFadden for Clemson, then I'd rather have Terry Grand than McFadden for us. Makes about as much sense (i.e. homer pick) I suppose;)

[sffanmike25]

McFadden is in a class all by himself.

.

[Brad]

Yep, just imagine McFadden in a non-one dimensional offense.

Hart = slow. Leader? Maybe. But so is McFadden. He nearly single-handedly brought Arkansas back from a 21 point deficit.

If you would rather have Davis than McFadden for Clemson, then I'd rather have Terry Grand than McFadden for us. Makes about as much sense (i.e. homer pick) I suppose;)


I did not say better. I said "not sure but up there" Hart is not super fast but hits the hole and does not stop running. Also from Oregon game where he injurs his thigh, he waives off his substitute, and tries to get the O-line to block. That next play he stands up a defensive lineman to allow Mallett time to throw.
I think Davis may be a better pro since my impression of McFadden is more of a East-West runner than North-South. However, I do not really watch Arkansas too often. Davis and Hart are definitley top 10 backs, possibley top 5

[pence23]

He really doesnt have an equal or anyone close

[redandpewter55]

Knowshon Moreno :dance:








Honestly, nobody compares to McFadden.

[trojanfan43]

I don't think there is another RB out there who I would want in the 1st round of next years draft.....the guy is a natural ball carrier.

[oregonweim]

McFadden is in a class with Stewart.

Sorry, and call me a homer, but if you offered McFadden straight up in trade for Jonathan, I'd probably decline. Slightly different styles but he is a beast. Sadly he isn't featured more in the offense, but statistically has comparable numbers to McFadden.

Here are some clips for you to enjoy, heh....


Jonathan Stewart: the future (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h2yKRVAHItU)
vs ASU (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qCZJfJ4ZS0Q&NR)
05 Highlights (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nwSKFOfc04Q&mode=related&search=)
88 Yrd TD vs FSU (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PLS6C0HKrMc)
Michigan game highlights, he is 28 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cm0jCiLv9Ds&NR=1)

[rexvos]

Sorry, and call me a homer, but if you offered McFadden straight up in trade for Jonathan, I'd probably decline. Slightly different styles but he is a beast. Sadly he isn't featured more in the offense, but statistically has comparable numbers to McFadden.

Here are some clips for you to enjoy, heh....


Jonathan Stewart: the future (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h2yKRVAHItU)
vs ASU (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qCZJfJ4ZS0Q&NR)
05 Highlights (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nwSKFOfc04Q&mode=related&search=)
88 Yrd TD vs FSU (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PLS6C0HKrMc)
Michigan game highlights, he is 28 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cm0jCiLv9Ds&NR=1)

that is the a completely moronic statement. A true homer. Way to make everyone else take every other comment you make with a grain of salt there homeboy.

[oregonweim]

watch it or I'll give the Oregon mascot your home address... he is off suspension now you know.